Good and bad gig experiences

New bands are welcome
Post Reply
User avatar
gerryuk
Kitchen
Posts: 109
Joined: Tue Jul 05, 2005 2:56 pm
Location: Birmingham UK

Good and bad gig experiences

Post by gerryuk »

Following on from my comments about Ms Chan Marshall (aka Catpower) on another thread, how about people posting some of their best and worst gig experiences.

Some of the best

Numerous Rush gigs when I was younger and they were in their pomp, I really would get transported to another world when I was at a Rush gig.

Numerous Kristin Hersh gigs (she is a total genius) but particular one brilliant acoustic show she did at the ULC in London (the hips and makers tour) in fact I arrived at the venue early and was lucky enough to experience her play a sound check of 4 songs with no one else in the venue, just me, absolutely magical.

All the Keneckie gigs I ever went to see, basically because they were such a wonderful indie pop group and because Lauren Laverne and Marie du Santiago were the best comedy double act ever to pick up guitars, enchanting.

Throwing Muses at the Shepherds Bush Empire (crap venue), I guess I was in the zone for this, my favourite band of all time, playing some of my favourite songs of all time. When Kristin launched into ‘hook in your head’ I though I had died and gone to heaven.

Belly at the Birmingham Institute. This was great because Belly were just such a fantastic live experience, and because the crowd involvement was so perfect, absolute joy and mania, but with no aggression.

Sleater Kinney (1) in a small pub in Portland, this was great because it was so unexpected I was on holiday and visiting Portland when I literally stumbled into the pub only to find out that Sleater-Kinney were playing a gig to try out new material (for those unfamiliar with Sleater-Kinney they all lived in Portland), it was a riot, made even better by the fact they came on stage at 12.30am, which meant I was conscious of the fact that whilst I was watching them, my work colleagues back in the UK would have just been arriving for work :lol: .

Sleater Kinney (2) at the Fillmore (?) in San Francisco. This was brilliant because I was on holiday and read about them in the local student mag, who headlined the article with the words ‘the saviours of rock’ I thought I cant miss this opportunity I will go check them out, and blow me down with a feather they sounded brilliant. Really visceral, I fell in love with them instantly.

Joanne Newsom: she played about 4 years ago at a lovely small venue local to me called the glee club, just Jo and her harp, she was absolutely mesmerising, I can honestly say it was the last time I have felt totally blown away at a gig.


Magnapop at Birmingham Edwards no8 club, well just for the unbound joyous musical experience they deliver, they must be the most underrated group of all time.

Some of the worst

Thankfully there haven’t been many but a couple stand out, the aforementioned Catpower in London, she was hopeless, catatonic almost, or just mumbled and looked down at the floor (she used to suffer from terrible stage fright, not great for a musician) a total disappointment, but as I say she is forgiven because she produces such wonderful music.

Mazzy Star: still the only gig I have ever been to where the band walked off, I say the band, really it was Hope Sandoval having a strop to end all strop. Here are some quotes from Hope (‘ I need silence to play these songs’ ‘you are all too quiet’ and ‘don’t you realise I am an artist’) did not go down well with one or two of the crowd who pointed out they worked week in week out in a crappy factory job and had saved up to come and see her, so why didn’t she just get on with doing her job.

Metric and Rilo Kiley both at the carling academy in Birmingham, not really the bands fault on these occasions, more the terrible acoustics at the venue, and the we are too cool to get involved crowd, oh and Rilo Kiley played too many songs from their last album which is less than average, ignoring their back catalogue which is magical :cry: .
you were walking through the house last night,
i knew it was you from the space in your steps

User avatar
sound world
Bedroom
Posts: 2987
Joined: Thu Feb 03, 2005 2:03 pm
anti-spam: No
Contact:

Re: Good and bad gig experiences

Post by sound world »

Oh I thought you meant our own gig experiences,ie gigs we have done.I can tell millions of stories but I'll save them for a muso website-I have a drummer mate whose entire website is given over to gigging horror stories. :mrgreen:
Most of the transcendent gigs I've been to have been jazz gigs because it's music of and for the moment.I think I've luckily forgotten most of the bad gigs.I remember a couple of terrible prog gigs in the 70s since when nothing's been quite so bad.

User avatar
Matt Butterfly
Kitchen
Posts: 110
Joined: Wed Sep 05, 2007 12:54 am

Re: Good and bad gig experiences

Post by Matt Butterfly »

I haven't really been to enough gigs to really compare.

I have only been going since 2006 because of the whole having to be 18 to get into a gig thing. But a consider myself a gig junkie now because I have been to so many in a short period of time. Over the last two years I have seen; Emilie Simon, Hanne Hukkleberg, Radiohead, Bjork, Keren Ann, Those Dancing Days, Jose Gonzalez, Super Furry Animals, Lykke Li, El perro Del Mar and Marybell Katastrophy. I don't regret any of them, luckily for me I don't have those embarassing "I don't tell anyone because I was young" gigs

Coming up I have: Emiliana Torrini and Sigur Ros this autumn. So very looking forward to both of those.

I consider a bad gig being a small one in which no one turns up, which was the Marybell Katastrophy. They are a small Danish band unheard of in the UK, but a very unique sounding band who like to experiment with rock, electronics and distorted voiced creating sounds that only they can create.

Check them out if that sounds down your road: www.myspace.com/marybellkatastrophy

"And when she didn't seem
to listen at all
He said I'm getting wet
You held your part
Of the deal"

[followed by sounds of rain]

barrett
Living room
Posts: 348
Joined: Fri Feb 04, 2005 12:12 pm
Location: elsewhere

Re: Good and bad gig experiences

Post by barrett »

The saddest gig i ever went to was The Meat Puppets in Manchester,1988ish and only a dozen people turned up :!: :!: :!: :!: :!: and 4 of them was us and we'd travelled 80 mile to see em,getting there early to make sure we got in.
Fuckin stunned !!!
Could'nt believe it !!!
they eventually came on stage,played their set as fast as fuckin possible and fucked off.

aermancer
Bathroom
Posts: 558
Joined: Fri Jan 13, 2006 6:53 am

Re: Good and bad gig experiences

Post by aermancer »

I've only been to a handful of concerts- Tori, Bjork, Joanna Newsom twice, The Fiery Furnaces, and Bat For Lashes. I think my favorite was The Fiery Furnaces because my friend and I met Eleanor before and after the show and she was completely lovely to us both times. :)

For some reason i wasn't too big on the Tori concert, mostly because I'm not a fan of her new album and when she played some songs solo with her piano she felt the need to fermata/draw out the word at the end of every sentence and it drove me crazy. I wanted to walk up there and punch her in the face and tell her to sing it decent.

RobB
Bedroom
Posts: 3969
Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2005 3:51 pm
anti-spam: No
Location: Essex, England.

Re: Good and bad gig experiences

Post by RobB »

aermancer wrote:For some reason i wasn't too big on the Tori concert, mostly because I'm not a fan of her new album and when she played some songs solo with her piano she felt the need to fermata/draw out the word at the end of every sentence and it drove me crazy.
From what I've read you're not alone as a lot of fans are getting annoyed by this vocal rearrangement.
Not that I'd ever go and see Tori live....I have her live NYC video and it must be one of the boring live concert videos ever.

User avatar
aftersea
Hallway
Posts: 31
Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2005 12:33 pm
Location: France

Re: Good and bad gig experiences

Post by aftersea »

i haven't been to many concerts but obviously, there are some gigs you just wish they were better...

the worst:
shannon wright, four years ago in small festival in the outskirts of Paris and one of my first concerts. i was waiting that moment for so long, maybe my expectations were too high...she didn't talk at all between the songs, no hello, no thank you, no good bye though the crowd was utterly cheerful!
so she just came on stage, played her songs as fast as possible. the sound was quite terrible. while she played her piano oriented songs, you could hear one another band playing at the same time next door.(the festival was in a building with two main stages in two separate rooms)
what a disappointment. still the coldest show i've ever been!

julie doiron: i couldn't believe it, there were only 15/20 people(and approx 5 at the end)...quite shocking! the first 40 min were
great though, but then, she didn't feel alright, asked for a glass of water, and apologized...she just couldn't stand up anymore! so her drummer
took place at the front(singing his own songs) while julie sat playing drums for a couple of songs. then came back singing a couple more of her own.
it could easily have been one of my best concerts! :(

camille: "music hole" tour, it's recent! got an invitation for a private show! it was so pompous and pathetic! an easy one to forget!


the best:
shannon wright this year :I . a very small european tour(5 dates) for no particular reasons, just for pleasure i guess!
in fact, a couple of weeks before the concert, i just didn't know she was going to play in town until a penpal told
me he was going to see her soon...it was so unexpected!then i checked her myspace...and noticed a french date!
of course, i was interested but it didn't cheer me up for all that because i was afraid...afraid to be disappointed again.
and i was short of money...so there were no opportunities for me to be attending it!
BUT the day before the d day, I WON a contest and managed to get a ticket!!!
it took place in an old but beautiful parisian theater with an uncredible high ceiling! i never thought it would be such
a perfect evening. she seemed so glad to be there, playing enthusiastically and perfectly each song for more than 1 hour! the setlist itself
was one of those setlists every SW fans would dream of!(with songs like heavy crown, hinterland...no less)
i would give EVERYTHING to see a concert like that one again!

i could go on and on, so i will spare you all the details :I ...but other memorable concerts include: nina nastasia, julie doiron, blonde
redhead, mai, promise and the monster, piano magic, an pierle, camille etc...

thank you for having read this :I

User avatar
caaaleb
Toilet
Posts: 15
Joined: Sun Jul 27, 2008 11:33 am

Re: Good and bad gig experiences

Post by caaaleb »

Aftersea, my best and worst gigs were also Shannon Wright.

The same gig.

It was a mix of the two you posted. I saw her solo show in Chicago almost a year ago and I met her before the show (I drove fifteen hours and stayed with some friends, mainly to see her) and she was -so- nice.I even took a picture with her. She remembered my name later after the show and gave me a huge hug. It was perfect. The show itself was amazing as well. She completely blew me away, but she played through each song pretty quickly with no words between songs and didn't play a lot of the songs I would've liked to hear. It was a nice mix though and definitely the best show I've seen. It just left me wanting so much more, and she doesn't really tour the states anymore. :(

I just saw the Silver Jews last week. They were pretty excellent.

Also, I don't listen to Tilly and the Wall at all.. but their live shows are very interesting with all the tapdancing and happiness.

Hm. I guess that's all for now.

User avatar
gerryuk
Kitchen
Posts: 109
Joined: Tue Jul 05, 2005 2:56 pm
Location: Birmingham UK

Re: Good and bad gig experiences

Post by gerryuk »

aftersea wrote:
the best:
shannon wright this year :I . a very small european tour(5 dates) for no particular reasons, just for pleasure i guess!
in fact, a couple of weeks before the concert, i just didn't know she was going to play in town until a penpal told
me he was going to see her soon...it was so unexpected!then i checked her myspace...and noticed a french date!
of course, i was interested but it didn't cheer me up for all that because i was afraid...afraid to be disappointed again.
and i was short of money...so there were no opportunities for me to be attending it!
BUT the day before the d day, I WON a contest and managed to get a ticket!!!
it took place in an old but beautiful parisian theater with an uncredible high ceiling! i never thought it would be such
a perfect evening. she seemed so glad to be there, playing enthusiastically and perfectly each song for more than 1 hour! the setlist itself
was one of those setlists every SW fans would dream of!(with songs like heavy crown, hinterland...no less)
i would give EVERYTHING to see a concert like that one again!

i could go on and on, so i will spare you all the details :I ...but other memorable concerts include: nina nastasia, julie doiron, blonde
redhead, mai, promise and the monster, piano magic, an pierle, camille etc...

thank you for having read this :I

I cant believe Shannon Wright played in Europe and I missed her :cry: :cry: , that makes me so upset, I love her, I love her, I love her. Great that she has another fan on this forum though, what great taste we have in music, stina and shannon :D
you were walking through the house last night,
i knew it was you from the space in your steps

RobB
Bedroom
Posts: 3969
Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2005 3:51 pm
anti-spam: No
Location: Essex, England.

Re: Good and bad gig experiences

Post by RobB »

The only disappointing gig I've been to was in (i think) 1987 when I saw Roger Waters at Wembley Arena. I was so bored that I began counting the empty seats in the upper tier opposite. :mrgreen:

User avatar
sound world
Bedroom
Posts: 2987
Joined: Thu Feb 03, 2005 2:03 pm
anti-spam: No
Contact:

Re: Good and bad gig experiences

Post by sound world »

Among the thousands of gigs/concerts I have attended or taken part in,there have been several occasions where I never got to see what I'd paid- or turned up- for.
Way back when I was a student,I was going to see Al Stewart-he never arrived at the gig,no explanation given.
A couple of weeks later I went to see a band whose name I've completely forgotten,they had one minor hit with 'They shoot horses,don't they?',and they didn't show up either.Their van had broken down or something.
A few years later I was going to see The Clash,but they cancelled because Joe Strummer had disappeared. :?:

Most of the above,I wasn't too disappointed by,but far worse was when I had a ticket to see Prince (in his late 80s heyday) and HE cancelled.I did see him later on,fantastic band.
Around the same time I got a ticket to see a couple of my heroes,trumpeter Don Cherry and drummer Ed Blackwell,but I had to cancel my attendance when someone in my family died suddenly.Not very long after,Don Cherry and Ed Blackwell were both dead too,so I never got to see them,shame.

And I've remembered (one of) the worst gigs I've ever seen. Being a pro musician myself,and having a degree in Music into the bargain,I expect other pros to at least have a modicum of competence on their instruments or with their singing/songwriting/performance/whatever. I saw Wreckless Eric in about 1991 and he was bloody awful. I like a lot of punk/that kind of genre because it has energy and commitment and honesty but Eric had very little of that,let alone any kind of musical ability at all. Plus everything was presented in a totally shambolic manner which seemed a put-on rather than genuine.
(On top of all that,I had just split from my current girlfriend,and Eric's rubbish just seemed like the soundtrack to my living hell.) :cry:

RobB
Bedroom
Posts: 3969
Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2005 3:51 pm
anti-spam: No
Location: Essex, England.

Re: Good and bad gig experiences

Post by RobB »

sound world wrote:Way back when I was a student,I was going to see Al Stewart-he never arrived at the gig,no explanation given.
Are you sure you don't mean Al Jolson? :mrgreen:

I remember that song 'They shoot horses don't they?'....in fact,I may even have bought the single at the time.
It was by a Welsh group called Racing Cars but I can't remember exactly when it was now.Must have been around the mid-seventies sometime.....its beginning to seem a long time ago anyway. :(

User avatar
sound world
Bedroom
Posts: 2987
Joined: Thu Feb 03, 2005 2:03 pm
anti-spam: No
Contact:

Re: Good and bad gig experiences

Post by sound world »

Racing Cars,that was it,thx RobB.And you're remarkably correct with time,I think it was '76-'77.Punk was just starting up.I was a punk attending classes in Harmony and Counterpoint. :mrgreen:

RobB
Bedroom
Posts: 3969
Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2005 3:51 pm
anti-spam: No
Location: Essex, England.

Re: Good and bad gig experiences

Post by RobB »

sound world wrote:I was a punk attending classes in Harmony and Counterpoint. :mrgreen:
You should have teamed up with Anne Stephenson,the first punk violinist to pogo her way out of the Guildhall School Of Music and Drama. :wink:

Just been doing a look-up in my book of chart singles and 'They Shoot Horses,Don't They?' entered the charts on 12th February 1977 and reached #14.
Their van broke down soon after I suspect.

Post Reply